Are Blogs Bad For Science?

There is a recent editorial by Geoffrey North in the scientific journal Current Biology about the dangers of social media on science. And although it’s titled “Social Media Likes and Dislikes” there is much more dislike than like.

In it, he quickly mentions the 2010 scandal about arsenic-based life, published to Science but ultimately found to be wrong (though it was not retracted and is still part of official scientific literature). The paper was found wrong the old fashioned way – in 2012 another group explained what was actually happening (the bacterium could selectively bind phosphorus in very aresnate-rich environments) – but everything started with scandal. There were many media reports and blog posts arguing back and forth the basis of the finding. Many by non-experts. North goes on to call blogs “vanity publications” arguing that they are not reviewed by experts or even pass through editors. He says he is not arguing against free speech, but “I do think there are dangers in a world where the critics are less accountable than in the more ‘traditional’ system of peer-reviewed journals.”

He bring up an interesting point, but (hopefully) readers understand that blogs are purely opinion pieces. They shouldn’t be taken as truth or scientific fact. Any idiot can make a blog (this one, case in point). So get out there and research things for yourself before developing a strong opinion about anything… or at least get your news from a trusted news source.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Are Blogs Bad For Science?

  1. I am probably following ~20-25 blogs. But, I don’t believe everything they write. What really annoys me is that a certain group of like-minded people come together and start to applause each other and overlook other people’s opinions and writings. Instead of being individuals, they act as a kind of “higher board of scientists” and judge people. I find this unacceptable and people like these can never be scientists even though they hold higher degrees in academia or industry.

    • I agree. I always try and keep in mind that blogs are typically researched, written and edited by a single person. That’s why gaining a reader’s trust is so important in serious blogging.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s